Tuesday, January 9, 2007

"Ask the IRB" session

Before I went to the "Ask the IRB" session, I am not quite familiar with IRB or Human Subjects Review Board. Then I knew that IRB is established to improve human subjects protection. After the session, I did some study about the ethics of research. Here are some notes I think we, as researchers, should keep in mind when conducting any research.
  • All researchers must be aware of and attend to the ethical considerations related to their studies. This need is important for all types and methods of research.
  • Two of , perhaps the most basic and important, ethical issues in research are concerned with participants' informed consent and freedom from harm.
  • Informed consent ensures that research participants enter the research of their free will and with understanding of the nature of the study and any possible dangers that may arise. Collecting information on participants or observing them without their knowledge or without appropriate permission is not ethical.
  • Freedom from harm is focused on not exposing subjects (participants) to risks. It involves
    issues of confidentiality (for example, to protect participants from embarrassment or ridicule) and issues related to personal privacy.
  • Access to data should be limited to persons directly involved in conducting the research. An individual participant's performance should not be reported or made public using the participant's name, even for an innocuous measure. Lack of privacy may lead to harm.
  • The use of confidentiality or anonymity to avoid privacy invasion and potential harm is common. Anonymity means that the researcher does not know the identities of participants in the study. Confidentiality is that the researcher knows the identities of participants but promises not to release them to anyone else.
  • Deception is another ethical dillemma. It is recommended not do the initial research studies using a topic that requires deception.
Ethical Issues in Qualitative Research
There are features of qualitative research that raise additional issues not typically encountered in quantitative research:
  1. Qualitative research plans typically evolve and change as the researcher's immersion in and understanding of the research setting grows. In a real sense, the research plan is "in process" and only generally formed when presented to the IRB. As the plan evolves with added understanding of the context and participants, there is increased likelihood that unanticipated and unreviewed ethical issues will arise and need to be resolved on the spot.
  2. Second, qualitative researchers typically are personally involved and engaged with the research context and its participants. The closeness between participants and researcher helps to provide deep and rich data, but may also create unconscious influences that raise issues for objectivity and data interpretation.
We might encounter ethical issues other than what I mentioned above in our research since there are many dimensions to the ethical conduct of research. However, I think the fundamental ethical rule is that participants should not be harmed in any way. Respect and concern for your own integrity and for your participants' dignity and welfare are the bottem lines of ethical research.

Reference:
Gay, L.R. & Airasian, P. (2003). Educational Research: Competencies for Analysis and Applications. New Jersey: Pearson Merrill Prentice Hall.

2 comments:

Stu said...

This is a wonderful first post! Keep up the good work.

Sung-Min Kim said...

Wow.
I supposed to attend Ask IRB session, but had another thing to do :(
I found IRB website and there is an important guide of student research. http://www.irb.pitt.edu/Student%20Research.htm
Hope this page will help you. :)